Amish Name Generator
Plain-community names from Lancaster to Holmes County
Generate realistic Amish names built from biblical and Pennsylvania German given names and the Swiss-German surnames of Old Order Amish communities, from the dominant few (Stoltzfus, Yoder, Miller, Troyer) to rarer settlement names.
About Amish names
Amish names are strikingly consistent because the population descends from a few hundred Swiss and Palatinate German Anabaptist families who arrived in Pennsylvania in the 1700s. In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, roughly a quarter of all Amish carry the surname Stoltzfus, with King, Fisher, Beiler, Lapp, Zook, Esh, Glick, Riehl and Smucker rounding out the list. In Holmes County, Ohio and northern Indiana the pattern shifts to Miller, Yoder, Troyer, Hershberger, Raber, Schlabach, Weaver, Mast and Bontrager. Knowing which cluster a name belongs to tells an informed reader where the character is from.
First names come mostly from the Old Testament and older German usage: Amos, Levi, Jonas, Eli, Menno, Elam, Enos and Mahlon for men; Mary, Sarah, Katie, Fannie, Lydia, Lovina, Malinda and Sadie for women. Because so many people share the same names, Amish communities rely on double names (Katie Ann, Sarah Mae, Eli Ray), middle initials (Eli J. Yoder) and 'Jr.' to tell them apart, along with nicknames tied to a father or trade that never appear on paper.
The names here mirror those real conventions, pairing Plain-community first names with the top surnames of the major settlements and with rarer ones such as Swarey, Whetstone and Neuenschwander. Men's double names like John Henry and David Lee appear too.
How to choose Amish names
- Pick surnames by settlement: Stoltzfus, King, Fisher and Beiler say Lancaster; Miller, Yoder, Troyer and Hershberger say Ohio or Indiana.
- Use double names or middle initials (Katie Ann, Sarah Mae, Eli J.) when several characters share a first name; that is exactly how real communities disambiguate.
- Avoid trendy or invented spellings. Amish first names are old, biblical and plain, so Jayden or Kaylee would break immersion immediately.
- For older generations, reach for names like Menno, Elam, Enos, Lovina and Malinda; younger Amish increasingly use Marlin, Wayne, Emma or Rosanna.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most common Amish last names?
Stoltzfus dominates Lancaster County, while Miller and Yoder are the most common across Ohio and Indiana. Troyer, Hershberger, King, Fisher, Beiler, Lapp, Zook and Schlabach are all extremely frequent.
Why do so many Amish share the same names?
The Amish descend from a small founding population and marry within the church, so a limited set of surnames spread across a large community. That is also why double names, initials and nicknames are so common.
Are Amish names the same as Pennsylvania Dutch names?
Largely yes. Pennsylvania Dutch (really Pennsylvania German) refers to the wider culture and dialect, and Amish and Old Order Mennonite families draw from the same Swiss-German surname pool, though Mennonites also use names like Martin, Horst and Nolt.
Can I use these names in an Amish romance novel?
Yes. The list pairs given names and surnames that are in real use in Amish communities, and no entry is meant to point at a particular person. Because so few names are shared by so many families, any combination may also belong to someone real, which is normal for fiction, games and other creative projects.
Related generators
Puritan Name Generator
Virtue names and colonial New England surnames
Dutch Name Generator
Realistic names from the Netherlands, tussenvoegsels included
Swiss Name Generator
German, French, Italian and Romansh Swiss names
Farmer Name Generator
Salt-of-the-earth names for rural characters
German Town Name Generator
Real German towns from the Baltic to Bavaria
Biblical Business Name Generator
Brandable names rooted in scripture
Amish Last Name Generator
Amish and Plain community family names
Mennonite Name Generator
Traditional family and given names of Mennonite communities
More like this
Dutch Renaissance Name Generator
Period names from Bruges to Golden Age Amsterdam
Dutch Last Name Generator
Real Dutch surnames with their particles spelled right
Pennsylvania Town Name Generator
Borough, township and patch-town names from Pennsylvania
Dutch Angel Dragon Name Generator
Everyday words for fluffy winged dragons
Baby Girl Name Generator
Beautiful baby girl names with middle and last name pairings
Dutch City Name Generator
Real and invented town names from the Netherlands
All 1,000 Amish names
A: 99 names
- Aaron Glick
- Aaron Jay Riehl
- Aaron Lee Detweiler
- Aaron Streicher
- Aaron Zehr
- Abe Miller
- Abe Nissley
- Abie Beiler
- Abie Kauffman
- Abie Stoltzfoos
- Abner Shetler
- Abner Stoltzfus
- Abraham Hershberger
- Abram Frey
- Ada Borkholder
- Ada Mae Hershberger
- Ada Mast
- Ada Raber
- Ada Ruth Borntrager
- Ada Sommers
- Ada Troyer
- Ada Zehr
- Adam Byler
- Adam Slabaugh
- Aden Barkman
- Aden Helmuth
- Aden N. Raber
- Aden Schlabach
- Aden Weaver
- Albert Beechy
- Albert Coblentz
- Allen Detweiler
- Allen Stutzman
- Alma Gingerich
- Alma Kinsinger
- Alta Mae Nisley
- Alta Schwartz
- Alta Yoder
- Alva Hochstetler
- Alva Nisley
- Alvin Mast
- Alvin Metz
- Alvin Yutzy
- Amanda Beachy
- Amanda Sue Troyer
- Ammon Bontrager
- Ammon Lehman
- Ammon Stoltzfus
- Ammon Zimmerman
A, continued
- Amos D. Beiler
- Amos Delagrange
- Amos Esh
- Amos G. Riehl
- Amos Huyard
- Amos Jr. Petersheim
- Amos Kauffman
- Amos Lapp
- Amos Lee Zook
- Amos Miller
- Amos Plank
- Amos Swarey
- Amos Yutzy
- Amzie Bontrager
- Amzie Lambright
- Amzie Wingard
- Ananias Schwartz
- Ananias Troyer
- Andrew Christner
- Andrew Girod
- Andrew Schlabach
- Andy Hershberger
- Andy Kemp
- Andy Lengacher
- Andy Mishler
- Andy Ropp
- Andy Schwartz
- Andy Troyer
- Anna Beiler
- Anna Erb
- Anna Flaud
- Anna Glick
- Anna Hostetler
- Anna Lehman
- Anna Lou Smucker
- Anna Mae Yoder
- Anna Mary Fisher
- Anna Ruth Esh
- Anna Smucker
- Anna Sue Beechy
- Anna Weaver
- Annie F. Lapp
- Annie Riehl
- Annie Slabaugh
- Aquilla Zimmerman
- Arie Mast
- Arlene Knepp
- Atlee Barkman
- Atlee Beechy
- Atlee Yoder
B: 33 names
- Barbara Ellen Fisher
- Barbara Hooley
- Barbara Jean Petersheim
- Barbara Kennel
- Barbara King
- Barbara Lambright
- Barbara Mast
- Barbara Petersheim
- Barbie King
- Barbie Zook
- Becky Allgyer
- Becky Riehl
- Ben Dienner
- Ben Gingerich
- Ben Kauffman
- Ben Yoder
- Bena Mast
- Benjamin Burkholder
- Benjamin Zook
- Benny Esh
- Benny Smoker
- Benuel Bawell
- Benuel King
- Benuel Z. Fisher
- Bertha Bontrager
- Betsy Stoltzfoos
- Betsy Zook
- Betty Ann Hostetler
- Betty Hostetler
- Betty Lou Yutzy
- Betty Wickey
- Beulah Eicher
- Beulah Hershberger
C: 35 names
- Calvin Bontrager
- Calvin Helmuth
- Caroline Graber
- Caroline Troyer
- Catherine Herrfort
- Catherine Hilty
- Catherine Stoltzfus
- Cephas Miller
- Cevilla Barkman
- Cevilla Schlabach
- Chester Schlabach
- Chris Esh
- Chris Zook
- Christ Allgyer
- Christ B. Riehl
- Christ Burkholder
- Christ Fisher
- Christian Bawell
- Christian L. Smucker
- Christian Mishler
- Christina Beiler
- Christina Neuenschwander
- Christina Wickey
- Clara Borntrager
- Clara Brenneman
- Clara Mae Gingerich
- Clarence Herschberger
- Clarence Yoder
- Cletus Hershberger
- Cletus Raber
- Cornelius Hershberger
- Cornelius Raber
- Cornelius Ropp
- Crist Kurtz
- Crist Schlabach
D: 49 names
- Dale Raber
- Dale Yutzy
- Dan Wengerd
- Dan Yoder
- Daniel Flaud
- Daniel K. Esh
- Daniel Lee Raber
- Daniel Ray Mast
- Daniel Schwartz
- Dannie Lapp
- Danny Raber
- Darlene Beechy
- Darlene Farmwald
- Daryl Eash
- Daryl Troyer
- David Graber
- David Hostetler
- David L. Fisher
- David Lee Schlabach
- David Ray Bontrager
- David Umble
- Davie Huyard
- Davie Riehl
- Deborah Smucker
- Deborah Umble
- Delbert Jess
- Delbert Schlabach
- Delbert Weaver
- Delilah Troyer
- Delmar Beachy
- Delmar Borntrager
- Dena Schlabach
- Dennis Schlabach
- Devon Bontrager
- Devon Lehman
- Devon Riegsecker
- Dinah Peachey
- Dinah Sharp
- Dora Kauffman
- Dora Mae Chupp
- Dorcas Brandenberger
- Dorcas Kanagy
- Dorcas Lapp
- Doretta Chupp
- Doretta Wittmer
- Dorothy Bontrager
- Drusilla Swartzentruber
- Duane Hershberger
- Duane Wagler
E: 114 names
- Earl Knepp
- Earl Nisley
- Eddie Bontrager
- Edith Eicher
- Edna Beachy
- Edna Bontrager
- Edna Gascho
- Edna Helmuth
- Edna Herschberger
- Edna Hochstedler
- Edna Mae Troyer
- Edward Burkholder
- Edward Nisley
- Edwin Detweiler
- Edwin Kuhns
- Effie Miller
- Elam Kurtz
- Elam Nafziger
- Elam Riehl
- Elam S. Stoltzfus
- Elam Smucker
- Elam Stoltzfoos
- Eldon Borntrager
- Eldon Mast
- Eli Christner
- Eli Herschberger
- Eli J. Yoder
- Eli Jr. Troyer
- Eli Mast
- Eli Ray Miller
- Eli Schrock
- Eli Steury
- Eli Swartzentruber
- Elias Troyer
- Elizabeth Ann Fisher
- Elizabeth Bontrager
- Elizabeth Neuenschwander
- Elizabeth Slabaugh
- Elizabeth Stoltzfus
- Ella Hershberger
- Ella Mae Schlabach
- Ella Ruth Kuhns
- Ella Schmucker
- Ellen Plank
- Ellen Zook
- Elmer Esh
- Elmer J. Blank
- Elmer King
- Elmer Ray Yoder
- Elmer Smoker
- Elmina Jess
- Elmina Raber
- Elnora Borkholder
- Elnora Christner
- Elnora Mast
- Elsie Keim
- Elsie Kinsinger
E, continued
- Elsie Mae Hochstetler
- Elsie Raber
- Elsie Wittmer
- Elva Stutzman
- Elvin Esh
- Elvin Kauffman
- Elvin King
- Emanuel Coblentz
- Emanuel Hershberger
- Emanuel Lee Kauffman
- Emanuel Zook
- Emery Beachy
- Emery Bontrager
- Emily Kuhns
- Emily Nissley
- Emma Herrfort
- Emma Jane Zehr
- Emma Jantzi
- Emma Kauffman
- Emma Lou Hostetler
- Emma Mae Zook
- Emma Ruth Bender
- Emma Ruth Stoltzfus
- Emma Schwartz
- Emma Sue Miller
- Emma Wengerd
- Enos Beachy
- Enos Girod
- Enos Hochstetler
- Enos Raber
- Enos Ray Yoder
- Enos Ropp
- Enos Sommers
- Enos Wingard
- Ephraim Bender
- Ephraim Gascho
- Ephraim Zook
- Ernest Bender
- Ernest Mullet
- Ervin D. Weaver
- Ervin Farmwald
- Ervin Schlabach
- Ervin Schmucker
- Ervin Weaver
- Esta Raber
- Esther Ann Yoder
- Esther Graber
- Esther M. Raber
- Esther Mae Lapp
- Esther Petersheim
- Esther Steury
- Esther Wingard
- Eva Esh
- Eva Lengacher
- Ezekiel Otto
- Ezra Hochstetler
- Ezra Hooley
F: 23 names
- Fannie Bawell
- Fannie Ellen Ebersol
- Fannie King
- Fannie Mae Beiler
- Fannie Metz
- Fannie Peachey
- Fannie Wagler
- Fannie Weaver
- Felty Kurtz
- Felty Miller
- Fern Miller
- Firman Barkman
- Firman Schlabach
- Firman Troyer
- Floyd Borntrager
- Fred Shetler
- Fred Slabaugh
- Freda Raber
- Freeman Beechy
- Freeman Lambright
- Freeman Miller
- Fronie Fisher
- Fronie Renno
G: 12 names
- Gerald Hochstetler
- Gerald Otto
- Gertie Kanagy
- Gertie Weaver
- Gid Beiler
- Gid Ike Esh
- Gideon Ebersol
- Glen Mast
- Glen Shetler
- Glen Whetstone
- Grace Glick
- Grace Hooley
H: 25 names
- Hannah Allgyer
- Hannah G. Fisher
- Hannah Schrock
- Hannah Streicher
- Harley Hershberger
- Harry Kurtz
- Harry Mishler
- Harvey Bontrager
- Harvey Borkholder
- Harvey Hershberger
- Harvey Lee Helmuth
- Harvey Mishler
- Henry E. Hochstetler
- Henry Fisher
- Henry Jr. Smucker
- Henry Lee Lambright
- Henry Schlabach
- Henry Z. Dienner
- Herman Stutzman
- Herman Yutzy
- Hettie Renno
- Hettie Smoker
- Homer Wengerd
- Howard Chupp
- Howard Yutzy
I: 34 names
- Ida Bontrager
- Ida Farmwald
- Ida Gingerich
- Ida J. Yoder
- Ida Mae Hershberger
- Ike Frey
- Ike Lapp
- Ike Smucker
- Ira Gingerich
- Ira Kinsinger
- Ira Mullet
- Irene Metz
- Irma Frey
- Isaac Glick
- Isaac Herrfort
- Isaac K. Zook
- Isaac Kinsinger
- Isaac Riehl
- Isaiah Speicher
- Isaiah Yoder
- Israel Beiler
- Israel Renno
- Israel Sharp
- Iva Chupp
- Iva Schlabach
- Iva Slabaugh
- Ivan Hertzler
- Ivan Jess
- Ivan Miller
- Ivan R. Bontrager
- Ivan Ray Troyer
- Ivan Smucker
- Ivan Speicher
- Ivan Zehr
J: 63 names
- Jacob Beiler
- Jacob F. Glick
- Jacob Kennel
- Jacob Lee Zook
- Jacob Ray Weaver
- Jacob Stoltzfus
- Jake Blank
- Jake Petersheim
- Jakie Ebersol
- Jakie Kennel
- Jakie Stoltzfus
- James Hochstetler
- James Lee Beachy
- James Raber
- Jay Keim
- Jemima Hershberger
- Jeremiah Brandenberger
- Jeremiah Kanagy
- Jeremiah Stoltzfus
- Jerry Yoder
- Jesse Wickey
- Joann Hostetler
- Joann Weirich
- Joas Weaver
- Joe Stutzman
- Joe Troyer
- Joel Graber
- Joel Smucker
- John David Stoltzfus
- John E. Swarey
- John Henry Yoder
J, continued
- John Mark Troyer
- John Ray Hershberger
- John Weaver
- Johnny Byler
- Johnny Zook
- Jonah Raber
- Jonas A. Hershberger
- Jonas Albrecht
- Jonas Beechy
- Jonas Byler
- Jonas Hostetler
- Jonas Jr. Stoltzfus
- Jonas Ray Esh
- Jonas Riegsecker
- Jonas Wittmer
- Jonathan B. Kauffman
- Jonathan Raber
- Jonathan Swarey
- Joseph Lee Keim
- Joseph Metz
- Joseph Neuenschwander
- Joseph Roth
- Joshua Chupp
- Josiah Kline
- Josie Hershberger
- Judith Riehl
- Judith Speicher
- Judy Schrock
- Judy Stoll
- Junior Hershberger
- Junior Kuhns
- Junior Troyer
K: 19 names
- Karen Delagrange
- Karen Slabaugh
- Katharine Schlabach
- Kathryn Lantz
- Kathryn Smucker
- Katie Ann Stoltzfus
- Katie Blank
- Katie Etta King
- Katie Glick
- Katie Kauffman
- Katie Kempf
- Katie Mae Lapp
- Katie Mast
- Katie Nafziger
- Katie Stoltzfoos
- Katie Sue Riehl
- Katie Troyer
- Katie Zook
- Kenneth Troyer
L: 85 names
- Lamar Glick
- Lamar Zook
- Larry Hershberger
- Laura Hertzler
- Laura Kauffman
- Laura Mae Keim
- LaVern Coblentz
- Lavina Kemp
- Lavina Peachey
- Leah Neuenschwander
- Leah Ruth Smoker
- Leah Schmucker
- Leander Kemp
- Leander Schrock
- Leander Troyer
- Leanna Girod
- Leanna Hochstetler
- Lee Chupp
- Lena Bontrager
- Lena Yutzy
- Leon Beiler
- Leon Glick
- Leona Gingerich
- Leona Wingard
- Leroy Miller
- Lester Beachy
- Lester Schlabach
- Levi Beiler
- Levi Bontrager
- Levi Gerber
- Levi Hochstedler
- Levi Jay Hostetler
- Levi Jr. Glick
- Levi Lantz
- Levi Ray Gingerich
- Levi Slabaugh
- Levi Stoll
- Levi Stutzman
- Lewis Keim
- Lewis Slabaugh
- Lillian Petersheim
- Lillian Speicher
L, continued
- Linda Mae Mast
- Linda Yoder
- Lizzie Ann Beiler
- Lizzie Stutzman
- Lloyd Schlabach
- Lois Otto
- Lois Stutzman
- Lonnie Bontrager
- Lonnie Otto
- Lonnie Riegsecker
- Loren Farmwald
- Loren Plank
- Loren Yoder
- Lorene Mast
- Loretta Schlabach
- Lovina Bender
- Lovina Borkholder
- Lovina Lambright
- Lovina Mullet
- Lovina Schlabach
- Lovina Schmidt
- Lucinda Weaver
- Lucy Ebersol
- Lucy Kuepfer
- Luella Beachy
- Luella Riegsecker
- Luke Keim
- Luke Petersheim
- Lydia Ann Stoltzfus
- Lydia Coblentz
- Lydia Esh
- Lydia Fern Glick
- Lydia Fisher
- Lydia Lambright
- Lydia Mae Riehl
- Lydia Plank
- Lydia Roth
- Lydia Ruth Huyard
- Lydia Swarey
- Lydiann Esh
- Lydiann Kennel
- Lynn Schmucker
- Lynn Wengerd
M: 116 names
- Mabel Keim
- Mabel Zehr
- Mae Troyer
- Magdalena Yoder
- Mahlon Swartzentruber
- Malinda Ann Kanagy
- Malinda Barkman
- Malinda Bontrager
- Malinda Keim
- Malinda Kropf
- Malinda Stutzman
- Malinda Sue Zook
- Manasseh Eash
- Manasses Bontrager
- Mandy Blank
- Marcus Lambright
- Marcus Peachey
- Marian Kurtz
- Marian Nafziger
- Marie Jess
- Marie Kuhns
- Marie Troyer
- Marietta Coblentz
- Marietta Gascho
- Marilyn Whetstone
- Marilyn Yoder
- Marion Kline
- Marion Schrock
- Mark Allen Mullet
- Mark Ebersol
- Mark Hostetler
- Marlene Herschberger
- Marlene Troyer
- Marlin Raber
- Marlin Ray Kauffman
- Martha Ann Eicher
- Martha Gingerich
- Martha Sue Beachy
- Martha Zimmerman
- Martin Graber
- Martin Zehr
- Marvin Ray Hochstetler
- Marvin Schrock
- Marvin Troyer
- Marvin Wickey
- Mary Ann Stoltzfus
- Mary Elizabeth Kauffman
- Mary Ellen Beiler
- Mary Etta Schlabach
- Mary Glick
- Mary Hochstedler
- Mary Jane Troyer
- Mary K. Stoltzfus
- Mary Lantz
- Mary Raber
- Mary Shetler
- Mary Sue Bontrager
- Mary Swartzentruber
M, continued
- Mary Yoder
- Maryann Byler
- Maryann Huyard
- Matthew Erb
- Matthew Kuhns
- Matthias Lapp
- Matthias Schwartz
- Matthias Streicher
- Mattie Ann Kurtz
- Mattie Brenneman
- Mattie Graber
- Mattie Hershberger
- Melvin Brenneman
- Melvin Knepp
- Melvin Lee Byler
- Melvin Schlabach
- Melvin Whetstone
- Menno Bontrager
- Menno Borkholder
- Menno Byler
- Menno Erb
- Menno Hilty
- Menno Jantzi
- Menno Yutzy
- Merle Troyer
- Merlin Lapp
- Merlin Riehl
- Mervin Farmwald
- Mervin Ray Kurtz
- Mervin Schlabach
- Micah Kramer
- Michael Bontrager
- Michael Gingerich
- Mildred Hershberger
- Mildred Hochstedler
- Milo Weaver
- Minerva Gerber
- Minerva Helmuth
- Miriam Kanagy
- Miriam Kemp
- Miriam Mishler
- Miriam Nisley
- Miriam Ruth Dienner
- Miriam Sue Miller
- Miriam Weaver
- Mollie Stoltzfus
- Mollie Swarey
- Monroe Beechy
- Mose Eicher
- Mose Farmwald
- Mose J. Yoder
- Mose Miller
- Mose Weaver
- Moses Keim
- Mosie Allgyer
- Mosie Smucker
- Myron Esh
- Myron Smucker
N: 37 names
- Nancy Ann Byler
- Nancy Beechy
- Nancy Herrfort
- Nancy Mullet
- Naomi Barkman
- Naomi Detweiler
- Naomi Grace Hostetler
- Naomi Hershberger
- Naomi Kurtz
- Naomi Lapp
- Naomi Ruth Ebersol
- Naomi Sue Wengerd
- Naomi Umble
- Nathan Kanagy
- Nathan Wengerd
- Nathaniel Hilty
- Nathaniel Zook
- Neil Yoder
- Nelson Mast
- Nelson Nisley
- Nettie Eicher
- Nettie Weaver
- Neva Jantzi
- Neva Wengerd
- Nicholas Beiler
- Nicholas Herrfort
- Nicholas Petersheim
- Noah Eicher
- Noah Hochstedler
- Noah Jay Slabaugh
- Noah Kropf
- Noah Sharp
- Noah Zimmerman
- Nora Brenneman
- Nora Mullet
- Norma Wickey
- Norman Mast
O: 17 names
- Oba Borkholder
- Oba Mast
- Oba Yoder
- Obed Hershberger
- Obed Swartzentruber
- Omar Fisher
- Omar Lantz
- Omar Stoltzfus
- Omar Swarey
- Ora Herschberger
- Ora Yoder
- Orpha Bontrager
- Orpha Knepp
- Orva Bontrager
- Owen Chupp
- Owen Hershberger
- Owen Mast
P: 23 names
- Paul D. Gingerich
- Paul David Nisley
- Paul Henry Wengerd
- Paul Schrock
- Pauline Metz
- Pauline Schlabach
- Perry Miller
- Perry Nisley
- Perry Raber
- Perry Whetstone
- Pete Gingerich
- Pete Hershberger
- Peter Eicher
- Peter Hostetler
- Peter Neuenschwander
- Philip Byler
- Philip Lengacher
- Phineas Mast
- Phoebe Beiler
- Phoebe Swartzentruber
- Polly Bontrager
- Priscilla Beiler
- Priscilla Shrock
R: 72 names
- Rachel Ann Riehl
- Rachel Brandenberger
- Rachel Frey
- Rachel Lapp
- Rachel S. Beiler
- Rachel Speicher
- Rachel Weaver
- Ray Coblentz
- Raymond Hershberger
- Rebecca Ann King
- Rebecca Dienner
- Rebecca Ebersol
- Rebecca Esh
- Rebecca Jane Zook
- Rebecca Lapp
- Rebecca Mast
- Rebecca Smucker
- Rebecca Stoltzfoos
- Rebecca Sue Miller
- Rebecca Zook
- Regina Eash
- Regina Mast
- Reuben Brandenberger
- Reuben Detweiler
- Reuben Jr. Yoder
- Reuben Kurtz
- Reuben Smucker
- Reuben Weirich
- Rhoda Christner
- Rhoda Schlabach
- Rhoda Sharp
- Rhoda Weaver
- Richard Burkholder
- Richard Gingerich
- Robert Helmuth
- Robert Zehr
R, continued
- Roman Christner
- Roman E. Troyer
- Roman Hershberger
- Roman Raber
- Rosa Hilty
- Rosanna Borntrager
- Rosanna Chupp
- Rosanna Hershberger
- Rosanna Mast
- Rosanna Whetstone
- Rose Albrecht
- Rose Detweiler
- Rosella Mishler
- Rosella Schmidt
- Rosemary Weaver
- Rosie Burkholder
- Rosie Schlabach
- Roy Brenneman
- Roy Lee Bender
- Roy Miller
- Roy Weaver
- Ruby Ann Helmuth
- Ruby Beachy
- Ruby Hilty
- Rudy Christner
- Rudy Mullet
- Rufus Detweiler
- Rufus Schrock
- Ruth Ann Hershberger
- Ruth D. Mast
- Ruth Elaine Bender
- Ruth Hochstetler
- Ruth Ropp
- Ruth Schrock
- Ruth Streicher
- Ruthie King
S: 74 names
- Sadie Ann Lantz
- Sadie Detweiler
- Sadie Esh
- Sadie Fisher
- Sadie Mae Smoker
- Sadie Mast
- Sadie Renno
- Sadie Ruth Lapp
- Sadie Stoltzfus
- Sadie Swarey
- Salina Kemp
- Salina Raber
- Sallie Flaud
- Sallie Glick
- Saloma Yoder
- Salome Coblentz
- Salome Knepp
- Sam Glick
- Sam Peachey
- Sam Schmidt
- Sammie Blank
- Sammie Flaud
- Sammie Lapp
- Samuel B. Stoltzfus
- Samuel Jay Beiler
- Samuel King
- Samuel Lee Lapp
- Samuel Stoltzfoos
- Sanford Beachy
- Sanford Hochstedler
- Sanford Wengerd
- Sara Ann Yoder
- Sara Jane Detweiler
- Sarah Byler
- Sarah Ellen Ebersol
- Sarah Etta Beiler
- Sarah Fisher
S, continued
- Sarah Huyard
- Sarah Mae Fisher
- Sarah Riehl
- Sarah Smoker
- Savilla Hershberger
- Seth Coblentz
- Seth Riehl
- Simeon Blank
- Simon Mast
- Simon Renno
- Simon Wingard
- Sol Petersheim
- Sol Swartzentruber
- Solomon Helmuth
- Solomon Neuenschwander
- Stephen Esh
- Stephen Wickey
- Steve Blank
- Steve Esh
- Steven Ray Christner
- Stevie Dienner
- Stevie Glick
- Sue Ellen Weaver
- Susan Kuhns
- Susan Peachey
- Susan Schlabach
- Susanna Hershberger
- Susie Ann Troyer
- Susie Detweiler
- Susie E. Zook
- Susie Gerber
- Susie Mullet
- Susie Whetstone
- Sylvan Riehl
- Sylvanus Kuhns
- Sylvia L. Esh
- Sylvia Nisley
T: 14 names
- Tena Borntrager
- Tena Sommers
- Thomas Mullet
- Thomas Peachey
- Timothy Glick
- Timothy Wengerd
- Titus Wagler
- Tobe Hochstetler
- Tobe Yoder
- Tobias Kinsinger
- Toby Keim
- Toby Raber
- Treva Nisley
- Treva Riegsecker
U: 3 names
- Uriah Byler
- Uriah Kempf
- Urie Troyer
V: 22 names
- Valentine Kanagy
- Valentine Yoder
- Velma Kropf
- Velma Lambright
- Vera Mast
- Verna A. Schlabach
- Verna Herschberger
- Verna Hilty
- Verna Hochstetler
- Verna Lengacher
- Verna Mae Stutzman
- Verna Raber
- Vernon Bender
- Vernon Bontrager
- Vernon Miller
- Veronica Lapp
- Veronica Streicher
- Victor Lehman
- Victor Yutzy
- Viola Troyer
- Virgil Bender
- Virgil Christner
W: 26 names
- Walter Lambright
- Walter Wengerd
- Wanda Steury
- Wanda Yutzy
- Wayne Borntrager
- Wayne M. Schlabach
- Wayne Raber
- Wayne Yoder
- Wilbur Raber
- William Beachy
- William Mast
- Willie Keim
- Willie Schlabach
- Willis Hershberger
- Willis Shrock
- Willis Troyer
- Wilma Bontrager
- Wilma Farmwald
- Wilma Jean Slabaugh
- Wilma Ropp
- Wilma Shrock
- Wilma Yoder
- Wilmer Lapp
- Wilmer Petersheim
- Wilmer Zook
- Wollie Bontrager
Y: 4 names
- Yost Ebersol
- Yost Jr. Stoltzfus
- Yost Kuepfer
- Yost Lapp